[MPA] audio editor thoughts? Anyone?

[Jay Shaffer]

I disagree, PT is great for multi-track work but for two track editing? 
For what I do (game sound design and composing) nothing beats the 
ancient and venerable Sound Edit 16. Which unbelievably runs in classic 
mode. And no other program I've seen out there has a Bender tool like 
SE16 which I use all the time for sound effects. It is the only app 
that I NEED to go into OS 9 for anymore. And yes, I have PT free and 
Peak VST.
  I have tried the following apps in OSX:
Amadeus II
Sound Studio
Spark ME
Acoustic Core
Cacophony
Jasmine
Sound Sculptor II
DSP Quattro
I like Quattro the best, but I don't like Quattro $129 better than the 
free Spark ME which is my main OSX Editor. Sound Studio from Felt Tip 
software is also pretty good.
If there were no Sound Edit 16, I would buy Quattro.
Your mileage may vary, Humbly submitted.
--
Jay Shaffer
Composer/ Sound Designer
jshaf at jayshaffer.com
http://jayshaffer.com/
http://macaudioguy.com/


On Monday, July 21, 2003, at 02:40 PM, Bruce Maclean wrote:

> 2 Words: ProTools
>
> (Or is that 1 word?)
> On Monday, July 21, 2003, at 01:24 PM, Rick Latham wrote:
>
>> I have found Peak and Spark are both excellent programs.
>> All the best with you tests,
>>
>> Rick
>>
>>
>>
>>> From: <cmh at chariot.net.au>
>>> Reply-To: "Mac Pro Audio List" 
>>> <MacProAudio at lists.themacintoshguy.com>
>>> Date: Mon, 21 Jul 2003 22:54:46 +0930
>>> To: "Mac Pro Audio List" <MacProAudio at lists.themacintoshguy.com>
>>> Subject: [MPA] audio editor thoughts? Anyone?
>>>
>>> Hi
>>>
>>> I am testing out some mac audio editors. Are there any 
>>> thoughts/experiences
>>> on mid-price audio editors which could help on a decision? The later 
>>> 2 seem
>>> to have better processing options where as the first seems to have 
>>> more core
>>> editing features
>>>
>>> I am currently testing
>>> 1) peak le
>>> 2) spark le
>>> 3) dsp quattro
>>>
>>> This is for a lab setup which currently has peak le 2.6 running. We 
>>> are
>>> considering an upgrade to peak le3(4) however the upgrade would cost 
>>> about
>>> the same as buying a new editor from the other companies (hence the 
>>> option
>>> is open)
>>>
>>> Cheers
>>> C.
>
>