Was it perhaps in your 3rd year of applecare? Maybe that is the cutoff..... --- You wrote: Hmm, What's the trick to get it covered then? I tried to be persistent, and between that and being on hold with I think 3 different support personnel, I was on the phone at least a half an hour. The ironic thing was that I'd heard people on this list getting batteries replaced before, and that was one of the reasons I bought AppleCare before the end of my 1 year warranty. Then they tell me that unless my battery failed within some specific shorter time frame, it would not be covered by AppleCare. --- end of quote ---