On Dec 14, 2005, at 12:34 AM, themacuser wrote: > Yeah, but Apple sells the SuperDrive and iDVD as one product in new > Macs, so they can pay per drive I'd say. LaCie don't have a > software MPEG-2 maker. Exactly. So LaCie doesn't need a license to sell a DVD burner. Neither does Apple. However, Apple needs an MPEG-2 license to distribute iDVD which has the encoder in it. Apple selling iDVD and the SuperDrive as one product is the lock-in I so despise. It's perfectly legal to use iDVD with another drive. Apple purposely crippled it so it won't work to force people to buy their drives. Where this screws Apple customers over is where a person has a first generation PowerBook with no burner. You buy a Firewire burner and now it don't work with iDVD. This is utterly ridiculous because you can burn to an MPEG-2 image file with iDVD and save it on your hard disk. Then transfer the MPEG-2 image to a PC running linux and burn it to a DVD. Or you can burn it to a DVD with Disk Utility on a Mac. So if Apple wants market share, then quit being so stingy. For cripes sake, a hacker wrote a 165 kb patch in his spare time that enables iDVD to work with external burners, so it's not like Apple can't do it. Further, crippling iDVD so it doesn't "just work" when Lisbeth plugs in her Firewire drive doesn't exactly add to the much ballyhoo'd Apple user experience either. It's more like the Apple user experience is that you have to fight to get anything to work on a Mac because Apple purposely cripples it. -- Chris ------------------------- PGP Key: http://astcomm.net/~chris/PGP_Public_Key/ -------------------------