[MacDV] Recommendations for analog to digital

[SLarsonIH at aol.com]

Hi All,

I have the machine (MDD Dual), the software and am ready to get the hardware 
to convert my tapes, etc. to DVD. The local store has both the Pinnacle and 
Pyro units in stock. So, before I buy anything, I wanted to tap into the 
collective wisdom of you on this list. Here's what I'd like: I'd like an external 
converter that goes both ways with most of the common ports. I'd also like to be 
able to watch and record stuff off my cable system. I'm guessing that may 
require two different purchases. I'd like it to be Firewire based. Of course, the 
option of being bus powered would be a nice addition. Mostly, I'd like your 
recommendations and suggestions regarding the units you've used.

A while ago, I had looked at the unit from Formac, but have heard a number of 
negative reports, so I'm hesitant. I've read reviews of the DAC, Sony, 
Canopus and one other that I can't remember, but i wanted to get your input before 
buying. So, if any of you have had good or bad experiences with any of the 
converters, please speak up.

Thanks
STeve